In last month’s article we discussed whether or not the next generation can afford to take over the farming operation. I received a lot of feedback on the article and one response stuck with me. The question was posed, if the farm is not making ends meet now, how can it then be profitable to the next generation, especially being profitable enough for to bring in the next generation?
It was a very good question and had me thinking on a response for quite some time. I will first lay out a disclaimer (we attorneys are good at doing such) and say that I am not a farm economist. Nor am I versed in financial advising. In addition, not every farm is going to be helped by what I write in this article, nor is what I write about a good fit for everyone. I am merely going of off 14 years of law experience and having worked with hundreds and hundreds of farmers running just about every type of farm operation there is. Here goes:
1. Farm Structure: The sooner a famer can structure their farm as a legal entity the better. I prefer using an LLC, or multiple LLCs, because they are easy to maintain, cost effective to set up, provide excellent liability protection, and give great tax flexibility. Your farm is a business, so set it up as one. The benefits you will see are many.
2. Self Employment Tax: Often times a tax savings can be achieved by setting up the land in one LLC and leasing it to the farm operation LLC. In other words, being your own landlord can save on self employment tax. Although in leaner times the savings will be less, in good times I have seen clients save tens of thousands of dollars in self employment tax. Consulting with your CPA on this is recommended.
3. Insurance: Maybe it is just me, but it seems like every year insurance premiums go up. As far as liability insurance, a million dollars does not cut it anymore. A farm should have a few million dollars. But where does it end? Well, having the farm set up properly in the form of a farm operating LLC can alleviate the need for higher liability insurance coverage and save money.
4. Payments to successor farmers: Say we have a farm couple, Jack and Dianne. And, they have a son, John, who wants to return to the farm. However, the farm cannot support two families, and it is not in the budget to fully pay John for working on the farm. I have seen in these instances where instead of getting a full wage, Jack and Dianne transfer membership units of their LLC to John as compensation. I totally get the fact that one cannot live off of LLC membership units. However, if the farm can pay John some sort of wage, then payment by way of LLC membership units can be a great supplement.
5. Non Farm Business: I have clients that have all sorts of side businesses that provide outside income. From excavating companies, drainage companies, machinery repair…you name, they do it. Especially if there is synergy for the side company to co-exist with the farm operation. For instance, you start an excavating business and use your farm shop, tools, etc, for the business. Obviously this will drastically cut down on start up costs. My observation is that in tough times, sometimes the side company is what pulls the farm through.
6. Farm Service Agency Loans: I’ve heard varying opinions about obtaining FSA loans over the years. However, they have low interest rate, long term amortization terms, and the amounts have been increased as of late. Some of these loans have a 40 year repayment term which can spread out payments and keep them lower and easier to keep current during lean times. For young farmers trying to purchase land or equipment, sometimes these loans will make all the difference in the world.
7. Diversify: In several instances, I have had instances where a client has a farming operation that is simply unable to support another family member coming into the fold. In these instances, the clients diversified into contract livestock growing, specialty crops, or other types of farming besides conventional row crop farming. I have several clients that have gotten into contract growing. These clients, depending on the livestock involved, tell me the earnings can be $80,000 to $120,000 per year. That surely sounds like enough income to enable another member of the family to come on board. My main concern with these types of arrangement is that the farmer is at the mercy of the company they are growing for. So, one should greatly do their homework on who they are getting involved with and know the ins and outs of the contract that will govern the arrangement. Contract growing may not be for everyone, but several of my clients say they could not make ends meet without it.
8. Get help with grain marketing: Most farmers would agree that marketing grain is tough. Over the years, I finally conceded that whatever I did would be wrong, it just came down to was I a little wrong or a lot wrong in a given year. However, if you can average a decent price that is above cost of production, that will cover a lot of sins. Clients that have done the best with marketing have engaged firms to help them and, by in large, it seems to have paid off. A lot of farmers are spooked by hedge to arrive contracts (HTA’s) and options. But, once you get versed in them, you’ll likely never want to return to straight forward sales due to the increased flexibility. I know that was the case with me.
In the end, we all know there is no magic bullet when it comes to making a farm profitable. In the times we are currently in, no matter what is done, some operations are going to have a hard time being profitable. However, if the goal is to get the farm as profitable as possible so as to either a) bring in another family member or b) give the next generation he best chance possible to succeed, then all options should be on the table and we should continuously be looking at various options to be explored. The suggestions in this article may or may not be applicable to your situation, but for many of the farmers I have worked with, they have been.
Popular posts from this blog
Part I-Reasons Plans Do Not Get Established. (Authors’ Note : This will be a several part series discussing why the current method of farm estate and succession planning is not working. In this first part, we will discuss the current state of farm succession and estate planning and compare to where it was ten years ago) After several years of the farm economy in the doldrums, that past 2 years have seen a reassurance leading to record land and machinery prices, as well as just about everything else. Prior to this, many farms were not even sure they would survive long enough to need a succession plan. Now, we’ve returned to where we were around 2009, 2010, and 2011, when the size of farm estates grew greatly and made it very difficult, if not impossible, for farming heirs to buy out non farming heirs due to the large capital outlay. With land and machinery at all times highs, the difficulty is even now more profound. The
Part II-Reasons Plans Do Not Get Established. (Authors’ Note : This will be a several part series discussing why the current method of farm estate and succession planning is not working) Last month we discussed the fact that statistics show that in the past 10 years, there really has not been much in the form of improvement as to estate and succession plans being created by farmers. Overall, 75% of farms in the country do not have a succession plan, and that number is roughly the same from ten years ago. Probably a good follow up analysis, which I have never seen anyone perform, is of the 25% of farms that do have a succession plan, what percentage of those are successful? Continuing our march towards identifying what is wrong with farm succession planning and how to fix it, we need to first look at the upcoming “farmestateaggeddon” that will happen this decade. According to USDA data, a whopping one-third of America’s 3.4 million farmers are over the ag
Traditional Method of Farm Succession Planning Broken…. Here is How to Fix it. Part III-Income Potential over Asset Value Arrives at Fairness
(Authors’ Note : This will be a several part series discussing why the current method of farm estate and succession planning is not working) This is part 3 of a 5-part series regarding the authors’ view that farm estate planning in this country is broken and needs fixed, especially in light of “Farm Estate Armageddon” that will happen this decade when ¼ of all farmers retire and 2/3 of all farmers will be over the age of 65. Past articles can be viewed at www.farmlegacy.blogspot.com . Why is farm estate planning so much different than other businesses? Well, to answer that question, we need to break down and compare farming, in general, to other businesses. Perhaps one of the most glaring differences between farming and other businesses is that farming is an “asset heavy-income light” profession. Two years ago, before we had a rebound in grain prices, I asked a lender what he saw as far as a rate of return on assets for farmers. The answer was 0.3 perce